Joe Calzaghe is obviously a great fighter...

[ICB]

Out of the great 4, Calzaghe, Jones, Hopkins, Toney...... Calzaghe is the best1 on the form he showed to-nite he is the man.

Uhh no they all would still beat Joe Calzaghe at there best.

You need to learn how to hedge your statements ICB.

You can state what you state but it doesnt equate to being truth in any way, shape nor form. I happen to think Calzaghe would be competitive against any version of Toney, Jones or Hopkins.

It doesnt make me right though.

Just my opinion Miles like you have your's i never said im right but IMO, James Toney at his best was too good of a counter puncher. When he bothered to actually train. Wow what a fighter i recently watched him take apart Doug DeWitt i can't see Joe Calzaghe beating that version of James Toney.

A young Bernard Hopkins would of been too physical for Joe Calzaghe, it would be much like the Robin Reid fight except a more convincing win for Bernard Hopkins.

And RJJ would of pot shotted Joe Calzaghe, and countered him effectively off the ropes.

Joe Calzaghe wouldn't be blown away in any of these fights, i think just based on workrate. He would be able to outwork lazy James Toney in quite a few rounds.

And i think Joe Calzaghe could also stand his ground and win quite a few rounds off Bernard Hopkins, plus Joe Calzaghe could also win rounds by outworking RJJ on the ropes.

But i still don't think Joe Calzaghe would win any of these fights.