Congrats to Paul Williams.

[leftylee]

Beating A. Margarito, Quintana in a 2nd attempt (After getting schooled the first time) and a shot Sharmba Mitchell doesn't make you P4P top ten worthy IMO.

I have your boy just outside the the top 10, and if he beats Paulie im not sure where i'll rank him, because even though he has had a much longer career than quite alot of fighters on the list.

Fighters like Chad Dawson have got a strong resume recently, so it just depends on how you look at it.

I do P4P on who they have beat in there career. Unlike yourself you do it how they look recently.

Works different ways, hence why I don't like them

[Rantcatrat]

P4p lists are subjective, but why is Miguel Cotto still in the Ring Magazine's top ten? In fact, Ring moved him this week from #9 position to #8. Please explain that to me. Cotto has stayed on the list after Margarito beat him.

Was Mijares a top ten p4p when Vic beat him?

[ICB]

P4p lists are subjective, but why is Miguel Cotto still in the Ring Magazine's top ten? In fact, Ring moved him this week from #9 position to #8. Please explain that to me. Cotto stayed on the after Margarito beat him.

Was Mijares a top ten p4p when Vic beat him?

Christian Mijares was number 7 i believe.

[Rantcatrat]

P4p lists are subjective, but why is Miguel Cotto still in the Ring Magazine's top ten? In fact, Ring moved him this week from #9 position to #8. Please explain that to me. Cotto stayed on the after Margarito beat him.

Was Mijares a top ten p4p when Vic beat him?

Christian Mijares was number 7 i believe.

With Vic's recent wins, shouldn't he be a bottom top ten p4p?

I am sure there are other deserving fighters too.

Mind you, Nothing against Cotto.