Yeah, I would speak to the manager.. It's probably just some kid who thinks he's the cropping whiz and it just like,,, a little more,,, a little more,,, a little more, until there's almost nothing left...

If they don't have an asshole manager or are in a good mood or have good policies or whatever, they should be fine with reprinting them if you weren't happy with the originals... Just say i'm not a fussy person so I really wouldn't come back if it wasn't important to me... Who could say no to that?