Did Margarito peak?

[Taeth]

If you, Daxx, were paying attention to anything you would know that Mayweather is coming back. He has plainly stated he is looking for the biggest fight available at any weight. Also I, among others, would flatly argue that
1) Cotto wasn't necessarily the best WW in the world, Paul Williams has a valid argument as long as he is willing to fight at WW when he gets the oppertunity.
2) P. Williams isn't campaigning at JR MW, but fighting there because Margarito won't fight him.
3) You can call Margarito the top guy at Ww, but in this current situation he is not the linear champ, he is not recognized as the ring champ either, thus he is the top guy in the division but that is different being in the position Mayweather was in before he retired. There is a difference between being the top spot in the division and being the best fighter in the division. Clottey would argue MArgarito's top spot, Williams would, Cotto would like a rematch as well. Margarito position is also very precarious because whenever Williams or Mayweather feel like dropping in then Margarito drops to #3.

[Onix]

If you, Daxx, were paying attention to anything you would know that Mayweather is coming back. He has plainly stated he is looking for the biggest fight available at any weight. Also I, among others, would flatly argue that
1) Cotto wasn't necessarily the best WW in the world, Paul Williams has a valid argument as long as he is willing to fight at WW when he gets the oppertunity.
2) P. Williams isn't campaigning at JR MW, but fighting there because Margarito won't fight him.
3) You can call Margarito the top guy at Ww, but in this current situation he is not the linear champ, he is not recognized as the ring champ either, thus he is the top guy in the division but that is different being in the position Mayweather was in before he retired. There is a difference between being the top spot in the division and being the best fighter in the division. Clottey would argue MArgarito's top spot, Williams would, Cotto would like a rematch as well. Margarito position is also very precarious because whenever Williams or Mayweather feel like dropping in then Margarito drops to #3.

At the end of the day though, Mayweather is not back yet, and Williams is not in WW division at the moment. Margo beat Clottey and Cotto so that makes him the top guy until the other two decide to get back in. What if's, maybe's, hopefullys or otherwise dont count.

[DaxxKahn]

If you, Daxx, were paying attention to anything you would know that Mayweather is coming back. He has plainly stated he is looking for the biggest fight available at any weight. Also I, among others, would flatly argue that
1) Cotto wasn't necessarily the best WW in the world, Paul Williams has a valid argument as long as he is willing to fight at WW when he gets the oppertunity.
2) P. Williams isn't campaigning at JR MW, but fighting there because Margarito won't fight him.
3) You can call Margarito the top guy at Ww, but in this current situation he is not the linear champ, he is not recognized as the ring champ either, thus he is the top guy in the division but that is different being in the position Mayweather was in before he retired. There is a difference between being the top spot in the division and being the best fighter in the division. Clottey would argue MArgarito's top spot, Williams would, Cotto would like a rematch as well. Margarito position is also very precarious because whenever Williams or Mayweather feel like dropping in then Margarito drops to #3.

At the end of the day though, Mayweather is not back yet, and Williams is not in WW division at the moment. Margo beat Clottey and Cotto so that makes him the top guy until the other two decide to get back in. What if's, maybe's, hopefullys or otherwise dont count.

Thank You!.....