Quote Originally Posted by killersheep View Post
Quote Originally Posted by hattonthehammer View Post
ok here goes....

1-Manny Pacquiao
2-Ricky Hatton
3-Israel Vasquez
4-Paul Williams
5-Juan Manuel Marquez
6-Andre Berto
7-Miguel Cotto
8-Chad Dawson
9-Arthur Abraham
10-Juan Diaz
Hmmm don't want to get too nitpicky but..........I would like to hear your scenarios that have Cotto and Berto on there but not Margarito. It is questionable whether Vazquez's surgery will be successful and he may have to retire, even if he doesn't he will probably never be at the level he was. How does Hatton get to # 2? How does Juan Diaz get on the list before Campbell? I guess it's only fair now that I post my list to be picked apart by others

1 - PAC
2 - JMM
3 - Williams
4 - Margarito
5 - Calderon
6 - Campbell
7 - Dawson
8 - Hatton
9 - Rafa
10 - JML

I am assuming that B-Hop and Calzaghe will retire and that PBF will stay retired.
Assuming Bhop, Calzaghe, and PBF retire or stay retired.

Hatton's stock won't rise if he loses to Pacman.

JMM stays in the same place if he beats Diaz assuming Pacman beats Hatton.

Dawson's stock shouldn't rise after he beats Tarver again.

Does Pwill's stock rise if he beats Winkie Wright? How much? Who else will fight him? Maybe if he fights Forrest or Dzinzurik and beats them, he'd jump into the top five.

How about Nate Campbell? Does he creep into the top ten if he beats Funeka?