Oscar destroys Cotto, he totally outboxed Mosley in their second, outboxed Trinidad almost every round, made him look foolish and a terrible fighter. Gave Mayweather he second most competitive fight. Gave Hopkins 6 competitive rounds. Always fought the best guys, always held his own except against Pacquiao.

As for Cotto haters? Most people on here love Cotto like no other. He is a really good fighter, but his durability is hardly that great, and he isn't the best boxer in the world. He's definitely good, and one of my favorite fighters, but Oscar in his prime would have stopped Cotto in 6.