Quote Originally Posted by Taeth View Post
Quote Originally Posted by Preme View Post
Quote Originally Posted by Pugilistic View Post
I personally would have Dawson at 10.
Dawson got pasy johnson by the skin of his teeth, and beat Tarver, that's it. Man the guy looks like he has skills but has done nothing at all to be spoken about as a top 10 p4p fighter in the world right now... not even close.
He fought a really close fight with Glen Johnson regardless of who wins that one, he beat Thomasz Adamek almost every single round(The top cruiserweight in the world) and one of the best LHW's before Chad beat him, He beat Tarver almost every round, and he beat Eric Harding almost every round.

Are you honestly going to say Caballero deserves to be in the top 10 p4p more than him?

I honeslty think Wladimir Klitschko deserves a mention he has beaten a lot of name fighters and guys who are good at heavyweight since he last was knocked out, including avenging that loss. IMO I would have him above Caballero based on opposition.

Also I don't even think Caballero is as good JML, this kid beat Ponce De Leon way faster, Destroyed Andrade, Figueora, and now Medina all in the first round. I'm not sure if even Marquez or Vazquez will be able to handle JML I think he should be in there even anyone besides the two mexicans deserve to be at 122.

Also p4p isn't just about opposition, its how good you are, Mayweather before he had a huge resume was up there because people could see how good he was, Caballero isn't as good as Chad Dawson or JML thats why I don't think he belongs there.
If you take away the opposition argument, it becomes even more subjective though. Based on talent alone the whole list changes. When you bring in the mix of talent AND opposition it will still be gray especially towards the bottom of the p4p list, there are many fighters knocking on the door of the p4p list Dawson, Williams, Klitschko, Adamek etc. However you look at it though a good case can be made for Caballero, personally I wouldn't have put him there, but I don't really have a problem with him being there, he has a great resume and a style that could trouble just about anyone in the division.