floyd turns down Mosley....

[BoomBoom]

i can no longer defend the guy in terms of where he stands in the all time ranks. whether he's retired or chooses to come back and fight. as it stands he not an all time great. He's on the same page as calzaghe IMO. Good fighters with great numerical numbers.

I agree with that. Id say where ever they stand on the ATG rankings, they should be close...and neither too close to the top

[Pugilistic]

Even though i would love to see this fight, Mayweather has retired.

Its not like he is looking into other fights.

[ElTerribleMorales]

dude give the guy a fucking break, i'm not even a Mayweather fan and yet i'm sick of all this thrashing, hell like someone else mentioned he hasn't said he's interested in fighting anyone, and hell for most of you nothing he does will be enough, he can come back beat Cotto, Mosley, and then Pacquiao, retire again and then some of you will still be bitching that he didn't fight Berto or Williams, get off the dudes back already

[Von Milash]

Floyd = chicken. Bottom line.

[ElTerribleMorales]

Calzaghe = chicken. Bottom line.

completely agree with you on that one

[TitoFan]

Floyd who?

[zhubin]

I think this would be a fun fight. Floyd is the younger and more skilled fighter, but Shane has tremendous heart and seems to have gotten a second wind. I am curious how the inactivity will effect Floyd...he has not fought in quite some time...so if he does come back and takes on a fighter of Shane's caliber...he needs to be his usual sharp self.

[Andre]

i can no longer defend the guy in terms of where he stands in the all time ranks. whether he's retired or chooses to come back and fight. as it stands he not an all time great. He's on the same page as calzaghe IMO. Good fighters with great numerical numbers.

I agree with that. Id say where ever they stand on the ATG rankings, they should be close...and neither too close to the top

Me too.
Both great fighters with huge skills, maybe the best, but both left a few unanswered questions by treading too carefully when the time was ripe to go for it.