Was Jeff Lacy a fake or did Calzaghe ruin him?

[Trainer Monkey]

He was flawed and inexperienced,and not ready for Joe,to a degree,Joe did ruin him because now the kid doesnt have an ounce of confidence,sort of like how Taylor hasnt looked right ever since Hopkins

[AdamGB]

He was flawed and inexperienced,and not ready for Joe,to a degree,Joe did ruin him because now the kid doesnt have an ounce of confidence,sort of like how Taylor hasnt looked right ever since Hopkins

That's along my way of thinking.

I'm more in between than the two choices here... He was supposed to destroy Joe, we all know what happened so he obviously wasn't as good as everybody was saying... but I think had he not taken such a beating from Joe and had he not injured his shoulder then he would probably be a much better fighter than he is today.