Who has more claim over the pac - hatton winner?

[J_C]

For enjoyment purposes id like to see any of the fights take place but I think Cotto-Hatton would make for the most competitive bout in my book. I think Moseley definitely beats both Hatton and Pacquiao if he shows in the shape he did in the Margarito fight.

Sorry realised I didnt answer the question! I believe its more a case of Pacquiao or Hatton having the claim. Pacquiao being the pound for pound fighter or Hatton if he beats the best pound for pound fighter. And I think both would want to and rather fight Cotto. So I guess my answer is Cotto.

[GAME]

For enjoyment purposes id like to see any of the fights take place but I think Cotto-Hatton would make for the most competitive bout in my book. I think Moseley definitely beats both Hatton and Pacquiao if he shows in the shape he did in the Margarito fight.

Defo

Mosley deserves this over Cotto because their fight was debatale but Mosley thrashed Tony .

[JazMerkin]

JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ

[Pravus]

Tough one. All three deserve the shot, but considering Marquez's brutal win tonight over Diaz and the fact his first two fights with Pacman were so controversial, I think JMM should get the shot. This is of course assuming Pacman beats Hatton (which isn't too much of an assumption for me).

[Gandalf]

I don't see the point in Hatton messing with 147 again. He doesn't have any issues making 140, and he's stepped up to 147 and had trouble both times. I would prefer him to stick at 140 TBH.

[fan johnny]

The fighter with the most fan based draw.