Even if it only till the outcome of Pac/Hatton JMM is PFP#1

[Spicoli]

Pacquiao DOMINATED his last 2 opponents with KO.
Marquez KOed his last 2 opponents too, but he did NOT dominate them.

Oh, what a silly comment.

Hearns blasted Duran
Hagler went the distance with Duran

Because of that, Hagler sparked Hearns out.
Did it matter that Hearns sparked Duran out when it came time to fight Hagler?
I'm all ears...

Yes, Teja greay analogy. You dominate an opponent and it means your better then someone else. Take off your Pac goggles you'll see things clearer.

It's about styles have you not learned anything.
Williams beats Margarito, Margarito beats Cotto, Cotto beats SSM, SSM beats Margarito.
You also have CQ beats Williams & Cotto beats CQ in there.

Great stuff Mick.Im having a hard enough time getting past the Avatar....sort of sums it up completely

[C-Lo]

I've said it before and I'll say it again...

...Pacquiao and Marquez are MADE for each other. Even when they're not fighting, they're still in competition. A third fight NEEDS to happen.

But on the thread topic, there's never been a co-P4P #1 and in this place and time, I wouldn't disagree that either man could be #1.

Ummm...Yea...they need to fight again!

[Spicoli]

Pacs departure from Light is clearly a financial move,he needs to get back and take care of an open ended chapter in a talent filled division.Marquez is shining with outstanding KO's over 'the man who beat the man' in Casa and a young,viable & dangerous Diaz.And no...thats not David Diaz.On skill depth,versatility,level of opposition and performance in with such,Defiantly Id say,right now Marquez numero uno p4p #1.

[Pavlik]

Even if PAC completely destroys Hatton on May 2nd people will question PAC's reign as P4P number 1. So I really pray hard that PAC-JMM3 happens

[CutMeMick]

Even if PAC completely destroys Hatton on May 2nd people will question PAC's reign as P4P number 1. So I really pray hard that PAC-JMM3 happens

No sir a win vs. Hatton IMO grants Pac the #1 spot.
He'd be beating THEE champ at 140 thus making him THEE man at 140.
Simple as that, anyone who think otherwise is clearly being biased towards JMM.

[Bomp]

Even if PAC completely destroys Hatton on May 2nd people will question PAC's reign as P4P number 1. So I really pray hard that PAC-JMM3 happens

No sir a win vs. Hatton IMO grants Pac the #1 spot.
He'd be beating THEE champ at 140 thus making him THEE man at 140.
Simple as that, anyone who think otherwise is clearly being biased towards JMM.

I agree, beating Hatton certainly trumps beating Diaz.

JMM's last two fights at lightweight have been a real eye opener, at first i thought he was a decent fighter who just happened to be a bogey man for Pac stylistically, but he is so much more. KO'ing two natural lightweights after campagining divisions lower throughout his career, he only went to superfeather to chase Pac back into the ring.

[Fenster]

Beating Hatton doesn't necessarily mean Pac goes above Marquez.

The reason I rate Marquez above Pac is because I think he beat him twice (especially 2nd time - like most people that rate Marquez better). Since the second victory Marquez has continued to rack up impressive wins (arguably better than Pacs).

So Pac beating Ricky enhances his standing but doesn't devalue Marquez. Unless Marquez loses anytime soon, loses to Pac or starts struggling against nobodies he will still have the victory over Pac, so has to remain ranked P4P no.1