Who is the P4P no1 today?

[Hunter]

Pac is #1 - Pac still owns a win over Marquez and Pac is still fighting/KO'ing top level competition like Marquez. This win doesnt warrant taking the top spot from Pac....Keep in mind Nate Campbell also beat Juan.......Juan wasnt bullet proof...JMM is #2

[Taeth]

Pacquiao is still the best, and he beat Marquez in their last fight if that isn't evidence enough, I don't know what is.

Obviously it is close, but I still could arguably see Hopkins slide infront of JMM. If you are like me and think Hopkins beat Calzaghe, and at very least a razor close decision seperated the two either way, after he already beat Wright, and Tarver. Then he went on to beat Pavlik. These guys except maybe Tarver are all higher up p4p than the guys JMM fought besides Pacquiao who DID beat him. It was a good close fight, but Pacman clearly won it.

[Fenster]

Pacquiao is still the best, and he beat Marquez in their last fight if that isn't evidence enough, I don't know what is.

Obviously it is close, but I still could arguably see Hopkins slide infront of JMM. If you are like me and think Hopkins beat Calzaghe, and at very least a razor close decision seperated the two either way, after he already beat Wright, and Tarver. Then he went on to beat Pavlik. These guys except maybe Tarver are all higher up p4p than the guys JMM fought besides Pacquiao who DID beat him. It was a good close fight, but Pacman clearly won it.

If you are like me and thought Marquez beat Pac then you'd understand why Marquez is P4P no.1

[CFH]

Just to do my part in debasing the legitimacy of this poll, I voted Hatton.

If I had to choose between Pac and JMM though, I would pick Pac.

[Pavlik]

Though not in his prime who would consider ODLH a lesser fighter than both Juan Diaz and Joel Casamayor. And for the record even if JMM skillwise is a better than PAC, PAC has inflicted the more damaging shots to Marquez on both fights. PAC beat JMM already regardless on how close it is. So obviously PAC is P4P number 1.
No disrespect to both Casamayor and Juan Diaz, IF Manny beats Hatton I think that is more of a feat than kayo wins over an aging Casamayor and a less than perfect Juan Diaz.

[Spicoli]

Regardless of seeing p4p ratings as pretty subjective and mushy,I'll say Marquez.Simply put,he is a better & more well rounded fighter in all around skills department.Pac has a nip & tuck win over him but Imo it has to be deeper than that.Now lets see what Pac does in with Hatton next up.

[leftylee]

Manny Pac is still P4P number 1 IMO.

I can't believe I've just said that, SaddoBoxer would be proud.

[killersheep]

I voted for JMM mainly because it puts PAC fans on the defensive and makes them say funny things like David Diaz was the Lightweight champ.

[antimoron]

well if we talk skill wise on active fighters then i vote bernard on that.. jmm beat diaz so does nate.. im not taking away what jmm did last night but still pac does what nobody can do to jmm today.. if pac beat old timers he is fighting old washup but if jmm beat an old one he is beating a legend.. double standard? maybe..

[HattonTheHammer]

Pacquiao quite rightly deserves to be considered as the p4p best even though many including myself think marquez deserved one if not both of the decisions when they fought.

Marquez leaps out into 2nd with only bhop, cotto and izzy taking up the chase

[killersheep]

PAC cannot even be considered p4p until he stops ducking Mighty Mike

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJGxQOwgZ2c

here you can clearly see Mighty dominating his opponent in a much great fashion than PAC over ODLH.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NwaKUgKvMtE

[Bomp]

I picked JMM, but it's real close. I thought he won the Pac rematch, couple that with his last two fights trumping Pac's (revisionist or not, Diaz on the weekend was a much livelier opponent than Oscar) and I think JMM shades it. Pac beats Hatton and he's back on top.

[JazMerkin]

PAC cannot even be considered p4p until he stops ducking Mighty Mike

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJGxQOwgZ2c

here you can clearly see Mighty dominating his opponent in a much great fashion than PAC over ODLH.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NwaKUgKvMtE

I'm with you killer, I can have nothing to do with any P4P list that does not include this Greek God.

[iwng100]

Just to do my part in debasing the legitimacy of this poll, I voted Hatton.

If I had to choose between Pac and JMM though, I would pick Pac.

This is your real thought or just the prediction for the 2nd may ?

[CFH]

Just to do my part in debasing the legitimacy of this poll, I voted Hatton.

If I had to choose between Pac and JMM though, I would pick Pac.

This is your real thought or just the prediction for the 2nd may ?

Nah, I'm just being a jackass. Thus the debasing comment. I really hope Hatton beats the shit out of Pacquiao though.