The Saddoboxing Sanctioning body

[killersheep]

I see what Spicoli is saying & it is valid...

but

I think a straight switch will not give us a clear representation of the true rankings.

e.g. using some of the current Ring rankings:

Judah #9 beats Mosley #1, sure Judah would have earned the #1 spot but would Mosley really be as far down as the #9 wekter in the world?

or

Garay #9 beat Dawson #2, I think Dawson would still be considered one of the best fighters in the division, not the 9th.

I think the fairest way maybe if your beaten the winner takes that spot & you move down one spot, moving the rest of the field all down one removing the 10th ranked fighter.

Maybe we could do a compromise, a normal loss 1 spot, a blowout 2 spots.

[Galaxy]

I see what Spicoli is saying & it is valid...

but

I think a straight switch will not give us a clear representation of the true rankings.

e.g. using some of the current Ring rankings:

Judah #9 beats Mosley #1, sure Judah would have earned the #1 spot but would Mosley really be as far down as the #9 wekter in the world?

or

Garay #9 beat Dawson #2, I think Dawson would still be considered one of the best fighters in the division, not the 9th.

I think the fairest way maybe if your beaten the winner takes that spot & you move down one spot, moving the rest of the field all down one removing the 10th ranked fighter.

Maybe we could do a compromise, a normal loss 1 spot, a blowout 2 spots.

I'm pretty sure most of us here are capable of telling the difference between a really close contest & a walkover.

e.g. Casamayor/ Katsidis was a very closley contested fight & although Katsidis got ko'd in no way would I call it a blowout. Vitali/ Peter on the other hand was dominant.

I think the final call should come down to yourself killer as I sure everyone on here respects your judgement. Atleast for now... once we start getting those sanctioning fees you may become curruptable!