Who do you favor in Khan vs. Barrera rematch (if ever)?

[Gandalf]

I think people are being too hard on Barrera and overrating Khan too much on the back of this "win". Most fighters would win rounds against an opponent with an injury like that.

Barrera still sparks him.

I think more people let their love for Barrera blind the fact that he has very little left to offer to Boxing. Time to retire me thinks

You could look at it like that.

But the truth is we were not given the opportunity to see what was left in the tank, Khan was able to "sparkle" in the most fortunate of circumstances.

As far as I'm concerned this past fight is not a proper means of judging how a rematch would go. I've always maintained Khan would start quickly and win the early rounds and that was made far easier by the cut.

5 rounds and a bloodbath is no barometer by which we can say Khan has Barrera's number.