P4P King?

**Taeth** · 04-22-2009 08:36 PM

IMO he would have to beat Manny as long as Manny is fighting around his weightclass, or Manny would have to lose in order for Mayweather to go above him, I think even beating Marquez wouldn't be enough.

**JazMerkin** · 04-23-2009 12:21 AM

Personally, I have Marquez at #1 right now, but if Pacquiao beats Hatton there can be no denying him top spot, although if Floyd does come back and win well then I might have to re-consider between the two of them.

**fan johnny** · 04-23-2009 01:56 AM

This was a good read on the subject.

Pound for Pound Dilemma: Who�s really #1? Mayweather or Pacquiao?

**eagle** · 04-23-2009 02:25 AM

If they both win a daresay we will see a showdown between the 2 and then all questions will be answered.

**Spicoli** · 04-23-2009 02:47 AM

Its alot if maybes right now.I have JMM at 1 and Pac 2nd,a win over Hatton puts him 1.They are the ones active and making big fights.As for Mayweather and what could,should,might happen,who really knows?

**Taeth** · 04-23-2009 02:59 AM

Complain all you want but Pacquiao beat Marquez, he isn't behind him, and shouldn't be in anyones p4p list. Casamayor was a shell of his prime self, yet despite the fact he was smaller, not as good to begin with, and put up a better fight against Marquez then Oscar did against Manny only furthers IMO the belief that Manny is better than JMM. Not only that but I know David Diaz isnt' as good as Juan Diaz, but JMM really didn't look superb against him, he looked good, but he was hurt several times and had he not stopped Juan Diaz it would have been close going in the scorecards, and he really wasn't dominating any of the rounds when IMO Pacquiao would dominated by midway against Juan.