P4P King?

[Fenster]

Pac has already beaten Marquez twice. The first one was supposed to be for pac had one of the judges not committed an error. Funny that they did not change the result even though the judge admitted the error. UNOFFICIALLY, Pac won against MArquez.

Second was very close but Pac had the nod of the judges so,OFFICIALLY, Pac is P4P #1.

No debate here.

Yes Pac officially has a draw and a win over Marquez. Going by official results it's fair to rate Pac higher.

But P4P is mythical nonsense.

We don't need to guess the outcome should these two fight. We have evidence of them fighting in their pomp in their best weight divisions.

In my view Marquez beat Pac twice. How can I rate a fighter higher P4P over a guy that has beaten him in TWO different weight divisons?

So in the mythical nonsense that is pound-for-pound - Marquez MUST rate higher than Pac.

But as long as you agree that this is just the mythical crazed Fenster/CutMeMick p4p rankings and not the Ring and officially recognised proper p4p rankings the its all well and good.

Of course Marquez still needs to beat Valero, the real linear champ and the man at 135.

I don't believe such a thing exists?

The Ring's list is just as crazed as Fensters.

I'll recognise the Saddo rankings even though they are clearly wrong. My list is the only correct one.. as any knowledgeable boxing person will agree. Fact.

[HattonTheHammer]

Yes Pac officially has a draw and a win over Marquez. Going by official results it's fair to rate Pac higher.

But P4P is mythical nonsense.

We don't need to guess the outcome should these two fight. We have evidence of them fighting in their pomp in their best weight divisions.

In my view Marquez beat Pac twice. How can I rate a fighter higher P4P over a guy that has beaten him in TWO different weight divisons?

So in the mythical nonsense that is pound-for-pound - Marquez MUST rate higher than Pac.

But as long as you agree that this is just the mythical crazed Fenster/CutMeMick p4p rankings and not the Ring and officially recognised proper p4p rankings the its all well and good.

Of course Marquez still needs to beat Valero, the real linear champ and the man at 135.

I don't believe such a thing exists?

The Ring's list is just as crazed as Fensters.

I'll recognise the Saddo rankings even though they are clearly wrong. My list is the only correct one.. as any knowledgeable boxing person will agree. Fact.

i`ll second that fenst......







you are the guy that has david haye at #4 arent you

[Fenster]

No I don't have Haye at 4.

I can probably make a case for him though.