Daily Show calls Truman a war criminal

[VictorCharlie]

I think you have to use the context of the time and not today. Total war was nation vs nation. Some very serious and catastrophic actions would have to take place today to see two super power nations wage total war against each other. Other than nuclear weapons falling into the hands of a mad man I cannot begin to fathom their use in today's world. From my reading and studies it is my humble opinion that Japan was not going to surrender w/o out an invasion of its main island(s). In the context of the time I think it was the right decision that I am sure was not come to in haste. I just think there is a lot of Monday morning quarterbacks out there that want to "what if" the topic to death. I think unless you are the President with the potential to end an unprovoked war of aggression while minimizing US casualties it is hard to second guess it.

[CGM]

Van, you make some valid points, about the context of the times and all. It's a tough call. Hard to agree or disagree with what you say.

[VictorCharlie]

Van, you make some valid points, about the context of the times and all. It's a tough call. Hard to agree or disagree with what you say.

I try to stay even handed with these issues. After two combat deployments I know what its like to make decisions that have human life implications, both of my Soldiers and civilians. I feel very blessed that I personally have never lost one of my Soldiers in combat. I just can't fathom having to make a decision where possibly 10s of millions of lives hang in the balance.