I think people are tripping on this post. You can't look for an answer comparing common defeated opponents. Lets be real, styles make fights is not just a saying. Cotto is a BEAST. He only got beat by a man with casted hands and he almost made it throught that. Look at all of the other fights. Cotto is the man at 147 right now and I'm sure he will outbox Clottey. Yeah, Cotto can box now and Clottey is the same old stand in front of you power puncher. Clottey is capable of hurting anyone and yes he is bigger than Cotto but not a significant deal since Cotto would not be so foolish as to stand in front of him. Cotto has gotten really good at using angles and I think had the "man of plaster" fight not happened then Cotto/PBF fight would be the only one that mattered. Cotto will beat everyone at 147 and under outside of PBF. Cotto over Clottey 8 rounds to 4. I'm glad that Cotto and Clottey are the types who will fight anyone and help clear up who is the king of a division. They both deserve credit for that.