You know... Iv'e really made a point of averting this discussion. I just don't want to get into a debate about it.

Why? Because the opinion is so split. There's just no point.

BUT, i will say that i have watched and re-watched and re-thought, and re-scored and then re-re-watched BOTH fights over and over (I'll be honest, i think the main reason is that both fights are so damn 'Watchable'. ). And i'll be honest Marquez won both fights.

Not only that, but at times in the second fight, Marquez impressed me so much i even started thinking about naming my unborn Son Marquez

Seriously talented, gutsy fighter is Marquez