
Originally Posted by
leftylee

Originally Posted by
Lyle
First off, Welcome Back my good friend.
#1 Evander Holyfield was a GREAT cruiserweight but he had to fight 5 heavyweight fights vs very good opponents before he got a title shot
#2 Collazo was a TITLE holder, Wladimir is the holder of multiple titles and is considered THE man of the division. Collazo was also out of Hatton's division by 7 pounds.
#3 JMM is one of the best pound for pound fighters out there, is David Haye
Wlad waited past February AND March and now he's supposed to wait until July?!?!?! Not that it's "unfair" it's just unreasonable...Wlad has better things to do than wait for David Haye to get fit.
What's pound for pound got to do with anything ? Just because JMM is P4P top 5 doesn't mean jack shit. JMM has never fought above 135 and now he's leaping to 143/144. Shouldn't Miguel Cotto who has proved countless times he is a force at the weight be more deserving and get a title shot ?
And Hatton never had one fight at welterweight before getting a title shot. Doesn't matter whether it was against "The man" or not he still got the chance to fight for an alphabet title in his very first fight.
This will be Haye's 3rd fight at HW and he already has 2 top ten rankings by the WBC and WBO so what's the problem ?
There are countless times a fighter has jumped up from one division to staright away fight for another. Nobody has said nothing about it yet all of a sudden when David Haye does it people say why is he getting a shot before others.
Haye has proved TWICE that he is a force in this division so I fail to see the problem. Even Wladimir admitted he would only fight Haye when he gets credibility in the divison. So Haye goes out and destroys Monte Barrett and gets the high ranking by the WBO thus gaining the credibility to fight the champion. End of.
First of all, I'm a David Haye fan, I train out of the same gym he did, & hope that Wlad only delays the fight a couple of weeks, as it will be more than worth it for the excitement, which I don't believe any other HW fight could match, and I think David could pull it off.
However, to even compare him to Juan Manuel Marquez is plain old ridiculous. Marquez is the kind of guy who has truly earned a shot at the best fights there are, by being an ATG & one of the best fighters in the sport today. David Haye just hasn't & isnt. Now, I have no problem with Haye leapfrogging the rest of the soulless HW division to get a shot, but that is only because of the paucity of the weight class. Also importantly, the PBF-JMM fight is not for any title, it's 2 guys who've transcended needing to fight for titles & are among the few who are now the image of the sport.
Also as impressive as Haye cleaning out the CW division was, it isn't comparable with JMM & Hatton simply because the quality of opposition was not on the same level. Now, like I said I still think it's fair enough because the HWs are dead right now, but Mormeck was no Tszyu or Casamayor & Enzo Maccarinelli was definitely not on the same level as Juan Diaz, and probably had no greater pedigree than Carlos Maussa.
I don't agree with Lyle that David doesn't deserve a shot at all, but to be honest that is more down to the state of the HW division, not down to how great Haye is, because had Hatton got an immediate shot at Floyd at 147, people would have thought it was ridiculous, because unlike a guy like Marquez he had not done enough before moving up to simply be fast-tracked to the best.
Bookmarks