Pernell Whitaker or Manny Pacqioau greater resume?

[OumaFan]

Whitaker's is better for now.

But LOL, some of you guys are talking about a top 40 all time fighter like he's some scrub. Chavez-Pacquaio is a great fight.

And making excuses for the first Barrera fight is so tired. Barrera was in or around his physical prime and Pacqauio annihalated him. Nothing fluky about it.

[JazMerkin]

Whitaker's is better for now.

But LOL, some of you guys are talking about a top 40 all time fighter like he's some scrub. Chavez-Pacquaio is a great fight.

And making excuses for the first Barrera fight is so tired. Barrera was in or around his physical prime and Pacqauio annihalated him. Nothing fluky about it.

Although, I didn't actually talk about Pac, I agree on the first MAB fight, people can't make excuses about Barrera's personal life, because they sure wouldn't do it if it was a less popular fighter. That was a fantastic win.

However, on comparing the 2, whilst Pac is a top 40 atg (right now), maybe top 30 for me, Whitaker is in most top 20s and in a lot of top 10s, hence why some reactions might be a little harsh, especially when you get certain people who act like boxing didn't exist before Pacquiao