I'm atually really suprised Donaire is so high in all honesty. His only win of note was his suprise ko of Darchinyan. Since then what has he done? He beat Maldonado but less impressively than Montiel did, and he's fought a couple of top 10 guys on little note.

He's only in the top 10 because Darchinyan has gone on to win more titles and at a higher weight, his own resume certainly doesn't warrent top 7 p4p status, not even close.

His inclusion is even worse than Christian Mijares and we all know how that went.

Seriously Juan Guzman, David Haye, Kelly Pavlik, Arthur Abraham, Tim Bradley, Shane Mosely, Chad Dawson, Thomas Adamek, they have all done as much if not more than Nonito Donaire.

It's the little guy positive discrimination at work again. These small guys fight in divisions that have literally (check boxrec) about half sometimes only a third of the competition that is to be found at the higher weights and yet people talk about their silky skills and boxing prowess elavating them far above what they really are.

Let's see Donaire actually fight and beat somebody first before he gets put as high as top 7 p4p.

I can't remember any other fighter getting rated so high for achieving so little. When he beat Darchinyan Vic wasn't even in the top 10 p4p and he's beaten no one of real significance since so why so high?

He's there because of what Vic has done since in beating Arce and especially Mijares.

The ring (and most on here) elevated Mijares well above his actual ability and when Darchinyan demolished him they have now elevated Donaire based on those results.

It's a farce in all honesty. It could have just been a bad night for Vic when he got stopped, lets see Donaire beat Montiel or Vic in a rematch before we all state he's one of the absolute world's best.

I'd rate Juan Guzman well above him.