Jones won but he should have never fought after that. He was tested which is what people wanted he faced adversity he won he should have rode off into the sunset. But he gave Tarver a rematch when he didn't want to and when he wasnt physically at his best, for someone who people complained never took a risk, continuing to fight after the first tarver fight with his body in the bad shape it was in had to be his biggest risks and ultimately it cost him dearly. Roy Jones just goes to show no matter how great of shape you are in, if you betray your body by losing 30 pounds or how ever many he lost, no matter how good your skill is if your body is drained so are you.