I'm not going to go into the general argument again as its been done to death but 143 was just a report coming out of the camp, that could easily be a negotiating ploy, we'll see how it comes off. If Manny insists on making it 143 then he's pushing it too far and Cotto should turn it down. But Bilbo is right, there's always context, its one thing to ask Paul Williams or Antonio Margarito to come down to 145 and its another to ask Cotto. Shane being somewhere in between probably.