Old Welterweight/Light-Welterweight/Lightweight threads

[Galaxy]

Sorry, the no option should read: Remove him to the Jr. Welter pool

[Galaxy]

With our new rule established, the option to vote a fighter who loses 2 fights in a row to the pool...

I put forward the motion that Julio Diaz (currently #6 at 135) be removed to the pool after suffering a KO defeat to Rolando Reyes & the a decision lose to Victor Cayo at 140

So should he remain ranked or be removed to the pool?

[Galaxy]

Jorge Barrios (in the pool at 130). His last fight at 130 was the stoppage to Rocky Juares on Sep 6th ’08 & his most recent fight was at 135. Should he remain in the 130 pool, or be added to the lightweight pool?

[killersheep]

I voted to the pool, if his next fight is higher than 140, I think we should remove him though.

[littlebif]

remove him to the pool there are decent fighters coming through and if Torres is'nt fighting he carnt defend his ringing spot.

[Spicoli]

With the given time line of a year with no match at weight as well as hitting the 2 year mark on Sept 1st with no wins,I say to the pool...leave vacant...with an eye on Bailey vs.Urango.Loving that fight

[Galaxy]

With the given time line of a year with no match at weight as well as hitting the 2 year mark on Sept 1st with no wins,I say to the pool...leave vacant...with an eye on Bailey vs.Urango.Loving that fight

Yeah bro, plus Malignaggi/ Diaz!!!

[Galaxy]

This poll has now closed. The results are as follows:

Ricardo Torres is removed to the pool by a vote of 6 points to 1 for keep him rated

[Galaxy]

This poll has now closed. The results are as follows:

Jorge Barrios is moved to the pool at 135 by a vote of 3 points to 2 to remove him all together

[Galaxy]

This poll has now closed. The results are as follows:

Julio Diaz is moved from the ratings to the pool by a vote of 7 points to none

[Galaxy]

How far should Paulie Malignaggi (currently # 5) fall after losing a close decision to Juan Diaz (#2 at lightweight, now entering 140 at #5)? 1-3 spots?

I vote he only drops one place; as it was a very close fight that could have gone either way.

[killersheep]

I had Diaz definately winning 3 rounds and Malignaggi definately winning 4 rounds with the other 5 being able to go either way he should only drop one spot.

[JazMerkin]

I've got to say I'm not keen on Diaz jumping Alexander & Khan who've had far more convincing victories recently, although I know those are our rules. I felt Malignaggi edged it, but the state of the victory takes away from the achievment for me.

[TigerFan]

One spot.

[Violent Demise]

I've got to say I'm not keen on Diaz jumping Alexander & Khan who've had far more convincing victories recently, although I know those are our rules. I felt Malignaggi edged it, but the state of the victory takes away from the achievment for me.

Considering the fact that the fight was fought at 138 and not 140, I say we don't even rank Diaz yet