does the winner of the SMW super six have a better resume than Calzaghe??

[Rantcatrat]

Well, Marciano already has a better resume than Joe... so you should say that Marciano will remain with an unmatched resume for 50 years Also, if we talk in matter of quality of opponent, Jermaine has the edge over Joe big time. Not saying he's better, but just like the violent one stated, quality of opponent for quality of opponent, Jermaine has a better one to this day and it is quite likely to think that he'll continue to face dangerous guys, no matter win or lose.

No he doesn't. If it's just about names faced then Calzaghe faced Roy Jones. Roy pisses over every name on Taylors record barring Hopkins. Calzaghe faced Hopkins too.

So Calzaghe wins this easy.

I would agree with you if he would have beaten a.. let's say, 33-34-35 years old Roy Jones and not a way pass its prime and fading 40 years old Jones.

Right, but Calzaghe was 37 at the time of the fight. It goes both ways.