i'll take hopkins...his going out a champ a master of his sport...roy went out depending on the talent thats no longer there...in the last fight with tarver he seem rather just stick his tongue out and shake his head then punch...as a fan of roy for so long...that was heartbreaking of what happen to him...he could of knock out tarver well atleast that was what i was hoping for...the roy we became a fan of never showed up...it was like find out santa clause didn't exist again...

hopkins still the same tough boxer...he came in a champ and his leaving a champ...