Should Calzaghe make a come back? Or should he hang up his gloves for good?

[Cleon]

He should stay retired

[THE THIRD MAN]

Stay retired, he beat two battle weary former champions at the end of their careers, ( it looks good on his record, but that's about all) he beat Kessler who was at his peak and that was a great win. My big disappointment with Calzaghe is we didn't see a rematch with Kessler, to me that would have defined him more than anything else. I'm not convinced he would have beaten Kessler a second time, Calzaghe had an opportunity to be part of a famous boxing trilogy.

[ryanman]

Stay retired, he beat two battle weary former champions at the end of their careers, ( it looks good on his record, but that's about all) he beat Kessler who was at his peak and that was a great win. My big disappointment with Calzaghe is we didn't see a rematch with Kessler, to me that would have defined him more than anything else. I'm not convinced he would have beaten Kessler a second time, Calzaghe had an opportunity to be part of a famous boxing trilogy.

Don't agree about rematch with Kessler. It was an entertaining competitive fight, but in the end Calzaghe beat him quite clearly.
Not sure he needed to prove it again.