Is Nonito Donaire really the 6th best boxer in the world??

[Kev]

Who had Margarito P4P top ten when Williams beat him?

And if you just look at each case I think you'd see that Calderon moving all the way up to 122 would be much more impressive, Williams is more just a freak of nature. Actually now that I read that again that's a horrible comparison.

Not that I disagree with Williams being in the bottom half.

After he beats Martinez he should be, what, number 1?

Like Vic Darchinyan Margarito crashed the top 5 p4p when he smoked Miguel Cotto AFTER Williams had alreadt beaten him.

In Darchinyan's case his post Donaire loss successes (wins over Mijares and Arce) were directly credited to Donaire who suddenly found himself propelled into the p4p on the back of Darchinyan's coat tails.

How does this work for the little guys but not for Williams?

Williams has won 3 world titles in two weight classes and has beaten a future hall of famer in another weight class. Donaire has never fought a world class fighter other than Darchinyan and not a single other world champ past or present is on his resume.

Who else in boxing has done so much recently ~(as Wiliams across 3 divisions) and isn't in the p4p?

[OumaFan]

1)I don't disagree with you about Williams, 2)that wasn't what you were saying and really wasn't an answer to my question and, 3)Darchinyan's post Donaire wins don't have asterisks by them.