Quote Originally Posted by OumaFan View Post
Who had Margarito P4P top ten when Williams beat him?

And if you just look at each case I think you'd see that Calderon moving all the way up to 122 would be much more impressive, Williams is more just a freak of nature. Actually now that I read that again that's a horrible comparison.

Not that I disagree with Williams being in the bottom half.

After he beats Martinez he should be, what, number 1?
So you discriminate against a fighter's achievements because he is tall? What about Tommy Hearns, does his conquering of many weight classes not mean much either?

Every fighter has strengths and assets and wins fights accordingly.

If Williams can win in 3 weights from 147 to 160 a difference of 13 lbs why is that less impressive than Calderon who has moved up a whopping 3lbs in his career?

Williams weighs around 40 percent more than Calderon yet in terms of rising through the weight classes has gone 400 percent further, 13 lbs compared to 3lb.

He's done more than Calderon for sure, any sane man should be able to see this.