Quote Originally Posted by Rantcatrat View Post
It's close.
  1. Mosley: he retains the #1 spot. He lost a razor thin decision to Cotto but then demolished a Margarito who had beat Cotto.
  2. Pacquiao: beat Cotto who was consensus #2
  3. Cotto/Floyd: has beat more top opposition at welterweight/jr. welterweight than any of the top guys: Clottey, Shane, Quintana, Judah, Malinaggi, Bailey etc.
  4. Floyd/Cotto: has not fought one consensus top ten welterweight in five years. Biggest win at welterweight was probably over Baldomir or Marquez who is a lightweight.
Now, a p4p list would look very different. But, I don't see how you rank Floyd above Pacquiao or Mosley and probably Cotto at welterweight at least if the list is based on achievements in the weight class because Floyd hasn't done anything at welterweight...ever really. I could see him above Cotto because of Cotto's recent losses, but even that's close call.

Also, unless I'm mistaken, isn't any fight above 140 but below 147 considered a welterweight fight?
I completely agree:
1. Mosley
2. Pacquiao
3. Cotto
4. PBF
5. Berto/Clottey