How high would you rank Manny in ATG if he beats PBF?

**BIG H** · 11-24-2009 10:08 AM

Originally Posted by mike_scfld

Pac at the moment is within top 7, to me way above Duran. Duran has a questionable heart (no mas, no mas) just a pure brawler doesnt have the beauty of in and out, lateral movement, etc. Pac is way better than Duran in style and resume. If he beats Mayweather he is absolutely within top 3. Pac is a combination of Duran and Leonard to me.

Floyd beating Manny doesnt make him at top 20. He should step up and fights better oppositions bigger than him like what Manny did all his career. at the moment he is fighting good smaller opponents bloating them up to his comfortable weights, eg. Hatton and JMM, far from being a great fighter.

Floyd fought for 8 years as a pro before he reached 140 (Hatton's career weight) DLH fought for the World Middleweight title, Zudah never lower than LWW, Baldomir a career WW.

Completely disagree with your Duran opinion too

**TheBranMan** · 11-24-2009 10:36 AM

Originally Posted by BIG H

Originally Posted by mike_scfld

Pac at the moment is within top 7, to me way above Duran. Duran has a questionable heart (no mas, no mas) just a pure brawler doesnt have the beauty of in and out, lateral movement, etc. Pac is way better than Duran in style and resume. If he beats Mayweather he is absolutely within top 3. Pac is a combination of Duran and Leonard to me.

Floyd beating Manny doesnt make him at top 20. He should step up and fights better oppositions bigger than him like what Manny did all his career. at the moment he is fighting good smaller opponents bloating them up to his comfortable weights, eg. Hatton and JMM, far from being a great fighter.

Floyd fought for 8 years as a pro before he reached 140 (Hatton's career weight) DLH fought for the World Middleweight title, Zudah never lower than LWW, Baldomir a career WW.

Completely disagree with your Duran opinion too

People will never be able to admit that Floyd has beaten the best. They will always say he has fought nobodys (yet you'll always find a number of these nobodies on their favorite fighters list). My argument is simple.. he just makes it look like hes fighting nobodies