Nigel Benn vs Roy Jones!

[Shamrock]

Nigel is one of my all time British favourites. If I go with my head I'd say Jones wins the fight by stoppage after 6 rounds.

In my heart though.... I keep thinking about the hammering he was taking from McClellan and still managed to come back. You can't teach that kind of heart. I'd love to think Jones had him hurt and followed in showboating with his hands down just as Nige fired a bone rattling right hook which put him to sleep.

I constantly go with my heart though and get it all wrong so Jones stoppage round 7

Benn V Toney would have been a war....

[El Kabong]

#1 McClellan allowed Benn back in that fight and #2 McClellan paid 0 attention to defense.

RJJ would have stomped out Benn, Eubank, Collins, and even Calzaghe had he decided to fight him earlier.

RJJ TOYED with top contenders and when he was serious he usually stopped the fight really early.

[ryanman]

#1 McClellan allowed Benn back in that fight and #2 McClellan paid 0 attention to defense.

RJJ would have stomped out Benn, Eubank, Collins, and even Calzaghe had he decided to fight him earlier.

RJJ TOYED with top contenders and when he was serious he usually stopped the fight really early.

When speaking of Jones, Eubank himself says in his autobiography -

'would i have beaten him? highly unlikely. Would he have hurt me badly? Almost certainly. Would i have hurt him? Yes. But not as bad as he would have hurt me.'

He went on to say thats why he didn't fight Jones but explains that he didn't duck Jones as if Jones was the no1 contender he would have done his duty and fought him.

[Pugilistic]

Roy would of outclassed Benn.

Jones would of probably stopped him early on imo.

[Shamrock]

#1 McClellan allowed Benn back in that fight and #2 McClellan paid 0 attention to defense.

RJJ would have stomped out Benn, Eubank, Collins, and even Calzaghe had he decided to fight him earlier.

RJJ TOYED with top contenders and when he was serious he usually stopped the fight really early.

I was there and trust me when I say that McClellan allowed Benn nothing... Benn forced his way back into the fight with pure heart.

[yvonne]

Nigel is one of my all time British favourites. If I go with my head I'd say Jones wins the fight by stoppage after 6 rounds.

In my heart though.... I keep thinking about the hammering he was taking from McClellan and still managed to come back. You can't teach that kind of heart. I'd love to think Jones had him hurt and followed in showboating with his hands down just as Nige fired a bone rattling right hook which put him to sleep.

I constantly go with my heart though and get it all wrong so Jones stoppage round 7

Benn V Toney would have been a war....

Its soo good to hear there's Benn fans out there on here.I just found him soo raw and exciting to witness.I've been watching his fights on dvd yet again.He caught my eye as a kid while i'd watch his live fights on t.v with me father.Nigel Benn was a true gent and game fighter.He was for me a really exciting fighter.I liked where he's go in sometime totally open and end badly stung and rattled but he just kept coming and firing heavy bombs,even sometimes leading in witha right hand lead,which caught out soo many of his opponants.

[skel1983]

Toney would be too much for Benn too imo.

[Master]

The timing was wrong, Benn was due to fight Jones after McClelland but I know Benn was finished by then.

[yvonne]

Benn at his best!!



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2TVgkCN_1aE

[Master]

With hindsight if Nigel did catch Roy, Jones would fall! Catching Roy would be difficult because he had great reflexes.

[El Kabong]

I actually think Toney would have had bigger problems with Eubank and Collins.....maybe it's just me but with Toney's defense and counter punching he may actually have stopped Benn earlier than Roy. Now Bernard Hopkins in his youth would have had SERIOUS trouble with Benn and Eubank....not so much Collins though

[El Kabong]

"If he caught Roy"....how many times has it been said and how many times did it actually happen?

How would a Benn-Jackson fight have gone?

[Spicoli]

I give a Primed Benn every bit an equal chance in this one,a fight that DEF should of happened after the McClellan tragedy.It was ripe and ready and much talked about but Roy could bank heavily beating the piss outta over matched and over hyped "people bought this crap" Pazienza with HBO's cushy contract and he knew it.He ultimately did not 'need' Benn,risk/reward.....but Benn EARNED that shot.

Much is made of Benn effected after the war with Gerald...and he was big time.Though to this day I think it also effected Jones Jr also.He spoke openly and often about permanent injury....not getting payed enough to fight this guy...or that guy and watching his good friend McClellan left in that condition ...which can happen to any fighter on any given night...sat with him for a long time.As it did anyone with a conscious and heart.

On paper and stylistically Jones out speeds,out shifts and out maneuvers Benn for a win.But Benn was all but assumed and second thought cannon fodder going into the McClellan fight.He was supposed to get pelayed and mashed....he was predictable,he was so open,his chin was known to take a bath when least expected and Gerald's path of destruction was flat phenominal....he literally layed waist to those in his path.Benn and Gerald displayed enough heart,grit and sheer will power to well up the eyes of many a man that night....I had goose fooking bumps as they went back and forth.Benn stood up to raw flush power shots and showed a tonnage of one intangible they do not and cannot measure on paper...Undeniable Desire and fortitude.He was no Merqui Sosa...Tony Thorton...Bryant Brannon or groomed for a blood letting of a showcase Pazienza.He was a Championship calibur fighter who was most dangerous when hurt,you simply had to respect that power or it would catch up to you.Roy had never faced anyone that fierce and unpredictably dangerous up to that point......and thats a fact!

[sumkalambay]

I give a Primed Benn every bit an equal chance in this one,a fight that DEF should of happened after the McClellan tragedy.It was ripe and ready and much talked about but Roy could bank heavily beating the piss outta over matched and over hyped "people bought this crap" Pazienza with HBO's cushy contract and he knew it.He ultimately did not 'need' Benn,risk/reward.....but Benn EARNED that shot.

Much is made of Benn effected after the war with Gerald...and he was big time.Though to this day I think it also effected Jones Jr also.He spoke openly and often about permanent injury....not getting payed enough to fight this guy...or that guy and watching his good friend McClellan left in that condition ...which can happen to any fighter on any given night...sat with him for a long time.As it did anyone with a conscious and heart.

On paper and stylistically Jones out speeds,out shifts and out maneuvers Benn for a win.But Benn was all but assumed and second thought cannon fodder going into the McClellan fight.He was supposed to get pelayed and mashed....he was predictable,he was so open,his chin was known to take a bath when least expected and Gerald's path of destruction was flat phenominal....he literally layed waist to those in his path.Benn and Gerald displayed enough heart,grit and sheer will power to well up the eyes of many a man that night....I had goose fooking bumps as they went back and forth.Benn stood up to raw flush power shots and showed a tonnage of one intangible they do not and cannot measure on paper...Undeniable Desire and fortitude.He was no Merqui Sosa...Tony Thorton...Bryant Brannon or groomed for a blood letting of a showcase Pazienza.He was a Championship calibur fighter who was most dangerous when hurt,you simply had to respect that power or it would catch up to you.Roy had never faced anyone that fierce and unpredictably dangerous up to that point......and thats a fact!

sorry but this is overrating Nigel Benn big time. Roy would've had Benn hurt early and finished him.

Roy was one of the best ever at reading his opponents and it showed when he faced the most technically skilled fighter in the sport at that time, James Toney. RJJ was an unbelievable ring general.

[ICB]

People keep saying we'll if Nigel Benn caught RJJ, but what about when RJJ catches Nigel Benn ?

Nigel Benn's chin wasn't exactly solid, and RJJ hit damn hard at Super Middleweight. And i'd certainly put money on RJJ catching Nigel Benn first, and finishing the job.

Nigel Benn was too reckless at times, and his defense was all over the place. He did improve somewhat in his laster career, but he was still very hittable.

If Thulani Malinga can give Nigel Benn hell twice, and if Michael Watson could outbox Nigel Benn and stop him. Then i'll for certain go with RJJ who would KO Nigel Benn within 6 rounds.