Fights Where you thought the official winner lost

[JazMerkin]

Pacquiao-Marquez II

Froch-Dirrell

Martinez-Williams

Cotto-Clottey

Ramirez-Whitaker

De La Hoya-Whitaker

Trinidad-De La Hoya

Calzaghe-Hopkins

Barrera-Morales I

Holmes-Norton

Bute-Andrade I

Soto-Lorenzo I

[The Fightfan]

Oscar - Mosley II
Oscar - Tito
Augustus - Burton
Ali - Norton III
Ali - Frazier II (One of the most overlooked robberies in boxing history)
Foreman - Briggs

[killersheep]

2010 - Shumenov/Campillo II - Campillo dominated the pace, defense, ring generalship, effective aggression and clean punching for most of the fight I had Campillo winning 9 rounds to 3. This was a horrible robbery.

[Lefty]

Taylor v Spinks
Williams v McDermott
Hopkins v Forbes

Horrible decisions those 3 fights.

[BIG H]

I think DLH beat Whitaker by virue of winning the last round - score cards were way out though!

[Pugilistic]

Williams - Martinez : Should of been a draw. Both fighters gave an excellent amount of effort.

Marquez - Pacquiao 2 : I had Marquez winning 115-112. I was more impressed with Marquez's well timed shots and how he was able to control the pace of the fight for the majority of it. Close fight overall though.

Calzaghe - Hopkins : I had Hopkins edging it 114-113. I was simply more impressed with Hopkins cleaner harder shots. Very close fight though.

Froch - Dirrell : I had Dirrell a clear winner. Froch came forward but landed very rarely and he was only successful really when he fought dirty which doesn't score points. Even though Dirrell over complained at times that doesn't change the fact that he landed he cleaner harder shots throughout and controlled the action with his superior boxing ability.

Mosley - De La Hoya 2 : I remember having DLH a close but clear winner. DLH outboxed Mosley behind his jab and i thought he took most of the early and middle rounds. Mosley had a late rally but in my opinion, it was too late.

[Dark Lord Al]

Calzaghe v Reid.
Calzaghe v Hopkins.
Johnny Nelson v Guillermo Jones.
Valuev v Haye. ( awful fight , i didnt think Haye would get the verdict in Germany ).
Reid v Ottka.

[nyc champ]

malignaggie vs diaz - malignaggie

wright vs taylor - wright

wright vs vargas - wright

judah vs spinks - judah

clottey vs cotto- clottey

williams vs martinez - martinez

[Mattyhitman]

Peter Buckley V about 50 opponents unluckiest boxer ever !

Oscar V Mayweather, i had him winning by 1 rd

Michael Brodie V Willie Jorrin.

Obviously two of the three Morrales V Barrera fights, two fights went the wrong way completely.


boxer dude ; are you serious with this one Quartey vs ODH - had quartey winning that one 114-113
I cannot remember Ike Quartey actually throwing a meaningful punch in the whole fight

[boxer dude]

Peter Buckley V about 50 opponents unluckiest boxer ever !

Oscar V Mayweather, i had him winning by 1 rd

Michael Brodie V Willie Jorrin.

Obviously two of the three Morrales V Barrera fights, two fights went the wrong way completely.


boxer dude ; are you serious with this one Quartey vs ODH - had quartey winning that one 114-113
I cannot remember Ike Quartey actually throwing a meaningful punch in the whole fight

How bout the punch that knocked Oscar on his ass?? u gotta watch that fight again Hittman, it was a very close exciting fight, I could see how u could score it for Oscar but Quartey not landing a meaningful punch the whole fight?? I think your way off on that observation dude.

[BIG H]

I had Quartey 114-113 too

[Mattyhitman]

Peter Buckley V about 50 opponents unluckiest boxer ever !

Oscar V Mayweather, i had him winning by 1 rd

Michael Brodie V Willie Jorrin.

Obviously two of the three Morrales V Barrera fights, two fights went the wrong way completely.


boxer dude ; are you serious with this one Quartey vs ODH - had quartey winning that one 114-113
I cannot remember Ike Quartey actually throwing a meaningful punch in the whole fight

How bout the punch that knocked Oscar on his ass?? u gotta watch that fight again Hittman, it was a very close exciting fight, I could see how u could score it for Oscar but Quartey not landing a meaningful punch the whole fight?? I think your way off on that observation dude.

I may have to watch the fight again, but i may fall asleep it was that bloody boring from what i remember, more of a chess match than a boxing match. I must have erased the match from my memory somehow and forgot the knockdown

[JonnyFolds]

Oscar - Mosley II
Oscar - Tito
Augustus - Burton
Ali - Norton III
Ali - Frazier II (One of the most overlooked robberies in boxing history)
Foreman - Briggs

Not sure about Frazier-Ali being that close. I do think it was closer than people remember it.

Oscar, Foreman, SweetPea, and Ali are the most cited?