Using this criteria Who's ranked higher all time?

[skel1983]

in ring performance
1-Leonard
2-Hagler
3-Jones Jr

Acheivements
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Dominance
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Mainstream appeal
1-Jones Jr
2-Eubank
3-Hagler

I believe Roy was more dominant than any of them and in ring performance roy rarely lost a round..and mainstream is a toss up between SRL,ROY,...Achievements is where its a bit "iffy" because roy achieved so much, but during a time where there was much more to achieve.


Guess I'd say Roy, then Hag or leonard, followed by BHOP...

Sorry mate but how the hell can you have Calzaghe ahead of RJJ in achievements? RJJ won world titles in Middle,super middle,light heavy and heavy??

[JonesJrMayweather]

in ring performance
1-Leonard
2-Hagler
3-Jones Jr

Acheivements
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Dominance
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Mainstream appeal
1-Jones Jr
2-Eubank
3-Hagler

I believe Roy was more dominant than any of them and in ring performance roy rarely lost a round..and mainstream is a toss up between SRL,ROY,...Achievements is where its a bit "iffy" because roy achieved so much, but during a time where there was much more to achieve.


Guess I'd say Roy, then Hag or leonard, followed by BHOP...

Sorry mate but how the hell can you have Calzaghe ahead of RJJ in achievements? RJJ won world titles in Middle,super middle,light heavy and heavy??

Was that for hitmanhatton or me?

[skel1983]

I believe Roy was more dominant than any of them and in ring performance roy rarely lost a round..and mainstream is a toss up between SRL,ROY,...Achievements is where its a bit "iffy" because roy achieved so much, but during a time where there was much more to achieve.


Guess I'd say Roy, then Hag or leonard, followed by BHOP...

Sorry mate but how the hell can you have Calzaghe ahead of RJJ in achievements? RJJ won world titles in Middle,super middle,light heavy and heavy??

Was that for hitmanhatton or me?

Not you lol I think it's safe to say you wouldn't rank Calzaghe ahead of RJJ in anything.

It was for Hammer.