Mayweather vs Pacquiao Resumes

[HattonTheHammer]

dont mind people believing floyd will beat manny and is fave going into that fight if it were to ever happen, but surely nobody can claim floyd has a better resume than pacquiao

floyds beaten hatton and marquez in the last 3 years

pacquiaos done that + barrera, cotto, de la hoya, clottey and diaz

[Althugz]

dont mind people believing floyd will beat manny and is fave going into that fight if it were to ever happen, but surely nobody can claim floyd has a better resume than pacquiao

floyds beaten hatton and marquez in the last 3 years

pacquiaos done that + barrera, cotto, de la hoya, clottey and diaz

Yeah but we're not looking at the last 3 years are we? We're looking at overall.

Overall, their resumes are a lot closer than people give Mayweather credit for..Is it better? Maybe..maybe not.

I can see the arguement for either side but if PBF's result against Mosley is positive it is as close as can be and perhaps advantage Floyd.

The point is if you dislike Floyd...You'll say he fought De La Hoya instead of a legit welterweight and he didn't put in a virtuoso performance like Pacquiauo did.

If you like Floyd, you'll say Floyd took on an even bigger challenge than any welterweight out there at the time by moving up in weight and conceding all advantages and winning. Where as Pac beat a corpse of De La Hoya which seemed to be no challenge at all.

For this reason, nobody will ever agree and why I think it is stupid to flame anybody who expresses an opinion in this particular type of thread.

There are no facts in threads like this. Just biased opinions based on who you like/dislike

[cleveland steamer]

The simple fact that the most noted and dangerous name on Mayweathers resume is 40 years old (and they havent even fought yet) should tell you something. And the fact that it took a massive earthquake to pretty much force Mayweather into reluctantly taking a fight with Shane should also tell you something. Even if he beats Mosley he still would need to do more to even consider getting the recognition he THINKS he deserves.