Fights where the result would have been different if the loser was in their prime

[ICB]

Well all of RJJ's losses except for the Montel Griffin DQ obviously.

[BIG H]

There are so mnay, I don't know where to start

These are just general, not in categories...

Like Ice said - all of RJJ's losses

All of Tyson's losses

Whitaker v ODLH (Whitaker lost that fight only by virture of losing the 12th imo)

Benn v Collins

B-Hop v Calzaghe

Holyfield v Lewis (I think Prime Holyfield could've beaten Lewis - 50/50 fight imo)

[HattonTheHammer]

A prime hopkins still gets whooped by calzaghe

As already been said anything with RJJ and tyson

[ICB]

I think Larry Holmes would be undefeated aswell, obviously he would still have alot of trouble vs prime Mike Tyson. But i still think he has the right style to beat Mike Tyson.

What about the 60's version of Muhammad Ali in the 70's ? would he have ever of lost ? as much as i don't like him, i actually can't see him being beat by Frazier, Norton, Holmes, Berbick, Spinks.

[skel1983]

RJJ V Calzaghe
Hopkins v Calzaghe

[ryanman]

RJJ V Calzaghe
Hopkins v Calzaghe

A prime Hopkins would have probably beaten THAT Calzaghe. But prime vs prime its Calzaghe all day for me.

[BIG H]

RJJ V Calzaghe
Hopkins v Calzaghe

A prime Hopkins would have probably beaten THAT Calzaghe. But prime vs prime its Calzaghe all day for me.

Very tough call, but I'd lean towards Hopkins, however as I've said before, I think Hopkins was nearer his prime that JC was at that time (strange to say I know) Hopkins best wins have all come past 40, his best performances were Tarver and Pavlik (which sandwiched the JC fight) JC's best nights were v Lacy and Kessler, cracks started to appear after that and I think he was 1 fight away from getting Koed

[ICB]

RJJ V Calzaghe
Hopkins v Calzaghe

A prime Hopkins would have probably beaten THAT Calzaghe. But prime vs prime its Calzaghe all day for me.

A prime Bernard Hopkins had hurtful power, and had very good workrate. He was great in his prime as a boxer/puncher, watch his fight vs Glen Johnson. No way Joe Calzaghe beats that version of Bernard Hopkins IMO.