Your top 5 fighters now.

[BoxingGorilla]

Off the top of the dome...

Cotto - He's been one of my fav since his debut
Martinez - Have seen him fight in person and he's even more amazing in person.
JMM - He's been one of my fav since 1995 for various reasons. An excellent fighter who even at this stage can outbox the yougest of lions.
Devon - Scoped him out since he beat Cuevas he was my fav prospect in 2007/2008 and just get's better and better.

The 5th spot is a tie between Montiel and Adamek...

I was expecting to see "Bad" Chad Dawson listed among your top 5. I'm sure he is in your top 10, right?

[CutMeMick]

I'm going to take Jeff Lacy off the lists now but he is definitely one of my all time favs, all his fights pre-Calzaghe were exciting and he had tenacity in there. Winky remains. Also I'm not going to include non-(ex)champions so guys like the Petersons are excluded. Edwin Valero would have been on this list too, sad.

1. Winky
2. Miguel Cotto
3. Andre Ward
4. Zab Judah
5. Paul Williams

Off the top of the dome...

Cotto - He's been one of my fav since his debut
Martinez - Have seen him fight in person and he's even more amazing in person.
JMM - He's been one of my fav since 1995 for various reasons. An excellent fighter who even at this stage can outbox the yougest of lions.
Devon - Scoped him out since he beat Cuevas he was my fav prospect in 2007/2008 and just get's better and better.

The 5th spot is a tie between Montiel and Adamek...

I was expecting to see "Bad" Chad Dawson listed among your top 5. I'm sure he is in your top 10, right?

Def in my top 10... I just went with the 1st names that popped in my head.
He's in my top 3, it would be Cotto, JMM & BCD in that order.

[Andre]

J M Marquez, balls skills heart and chin.
Lopez, slick.
Cotto ,I think he got ripped off and he wore it well, plus he always brings it.
Anyone else with the name Andre, who can bang.
Alan Donny Donnellan Because Im prejudice.