Ralph Nader

[El Kabong]

Interesting to see Lyle going against freedom of speech when it comes to Israel.

I'm not against freedom of speech at all, but let's say you said that at work what would happen to you? No one is putting her in jail, no one is assaulting her, they just said that what she said was wrong and they called for her job and she resigned....and rightfully so.

[Gandalf]

Interesting to see Lyle going against freedom of speech when it comes to Israel.

I'm not against freedom of speech at all, but let's say you said that at work what would happen to you? No one is putting her in jail, no one is assaulting her, they just said that what she said was wrong and they called for her job and she resigned....and rightfully so.

She apologised and that should have been enough. She shouldn't have needed to resign. Her comments were made outside of work hours and even if 'wrong' one is entitled to express what one feels. It was a witchhunt by a two bit media that refuses to ever rise up on the issues that matter. It was all quite unnecessary IMO.

[El Kabong]

She apologised and that should have been enough. She shouldn't have needed to resign. Her comments were made outside of work hours and even if 'wrong' one is entitled to express what one feels. It was a witchhunt by a two bit media that refuses to ever rise up on the issues that matter. It was all quite unnecessary IMO.

Sorry we disagree miles, but what she said was enough to cost her her job

[Gandalf]

She apologised and that should have been enough. She shouldn't have needed to resign. Her comments were made outside of work hours and even if 'wrong' one is entitled to express what one feels. It was a witchhunt by a two bit media that refuses to ever rise up on the issues that matter. It was all quite unnecessary IMO.

Sorry we disagree miles, but what she said was enough to cost her her job

Nothing wrong with disagreeing. We both agree that she spoke rashly, just disagree on how far the consequences should have gone.