Devon Alexander vs Andriy Kotelnik My Scorecard

[J_C]

I had it 7-5 Kotelnik. There was a TON of close rounds that I could see how they could go either way though. Every round 2nd-8th was a pick em imo (bar the 6th which Kotelnik took). On clear cut rounds I had it 4-1 Kotelnik and the other 7 rounds were just what you like really. I guess the judges scored every single one of the close ones for Alexander. I can see a draw but Alexander never deserved to win and in reality I think Kotelnik deserved the nod.

Round 1 Alexander won. Rounds 6,9,10,12 were Kotelniks. The rest were v close, generally a case of a massive disparity between mass activity against cleaner punching.

[gest12645]

It seems like the general consensus is that Kotelnik won 115-113. I had it that way too

[AirJordanIV]

I had Kotelnik up. He landed everything he threw. I take Bradley, Khan, Ortiz, or Maidana over Alexander. This may seem hasty. Devon has absolutely no head movement. Kotelnik was fun to watch.

[boxingbantz]

Just watched the fight again at work on my ipod and I had it 115-113 Kotelnik.I have no idea how Lederman had it 9-3 to Alexander. Absolutely staggering conclusion imo. He may have thrown a lot more punches most of his shots were blocked or simply were just punching air. Kotelnik landed a lot more than Devon did and snapped his head back a lot more. The unnamimous decision was shocking. Kotelnik looked gutted, he really thought he'd won.