Judah has/had wayyy more talent than McCall, so I would have to say that Judah wasted his talent more.

Still he was JW and WW champion of the world. And may grab a title at JW yet again.

And he went tit for tat with Floyd Mayweather for the first 8 rounds or so of their fight as well as dropping Mayweather and not gettin credit for it.

So not too shabby...

I think McCall aside from the second Lennox fight, really made the most of what God gave him.

Which is a huge physique, a GREAT chin, and some pretty good power.