So where he should he be p4p now? Froch Abraham Spolier

[gest12645]

P4P is not only about resumee but about performance. He lost to Dirrell imo, lost to kessler. looked bad against taylor. Looked average against Pacal.

But he did in fact look good against Abraham. Still I wouldnt have him in my top 20 .

[ICB]

Well in my own personal opinion, i thought he lost clearly to Dirrell, Kessler. But based on the record books i think he could slot in at number 10.

1 Manny Pacquiao
2 Floyd Mayweather Jr
3 Juan Manuel Marquez
4 Sergio Martinez
5 Fernando Montiel
6 Pongsaklek Wongjongkam
7 Wladimir Klitschko
8 Timothy Bradley
9 Juan Manuel Lopez
10 Anselmo Moreno

This was my P4P list.

1 Manny Pacquiao
2 Floyd Mayweather Jr
3 Juan Manuel Marquez
4 Sergio Martinez
5 Fernando Montiel
6 Pongsaklek Wongjongkam
7 Wladimir Klitschko
8 Timothy Bradley
9 Juan Manuel Lopez
10 Carl Froch

Have Carl Froch replace Anselmo Moreno.

[ono]

1: Pacquiao
2: Mayweather
3: JMM
4: Montiel
5: Martinez
6: Froch


So, yes 6th.

[BoxingGorilla]

He easily plugs into Klitschko's spot, that is certain.

[BIG H]

P4P is not only about resumee but about performance. He lost to Dirrell imo, lost to kessler. looked bad against taylor. Looked average against Pacal.

But he did in fact look good against Abraham. Still I wouldnt have him in my top 20 .

Yeh I kinda see it that way.

My take

Very sloppy against Pascal - but excellent heart and great win
Lost the first 35 and a half minuted to Taylor (fair play for getting him out of there though)
Lost to Dirrell
Lost to Kessler
Superb disciplined performance against AA

I am going to watch the Kessler fight today, becuase a lot of people think Froch could've nicked that, but I had Kessler a clear winner (when watching on live stream) So maybe I was wrong

[erics44]

P4P is not only about resumee but about performance. He lost to Dirrell imo, lost to kessler. looked bad against taylor. Looked average against Pacal.

But he did in fact look good against Abraham. Still I wouldnt have him in my top 20 .

Yeh I kinda see it that way.

My take

Very sloppy against Pascal - but excellent heart and great win
Lost the first 35 and a half minuted to Taylor (fair play for getting him out of there though)
Lost to Dirrell
Lost to Kessler
Superb disciplined performance against AA

I am going to watch the Kessler fight today, becuase a lot of people think Froch could've nicked that, but I had Kessler a clear winner (when watching on live stream) So maybe I was wrong

his win against passcal was quite convincing in the end, yes he had little deffence but he took over in the second half of a fantastic fight and you couldnt really argue that it could have gone the other way

He beat dirrell, i dont want to get into that argument tho because I think the fight should have been stopped by 6 rounds, dirrell was far far far too deffensive and too unwilling to fight to have any chance of winning the fight, the right man won

I think he beat kessler by a couple to 3 rounds, when you watch the fight concentrate on kessler for the first 5 rounds, i dont think in that time he lands a punch of any note where froch catches him a fair few times. I think froch finishes stronger too, they showed the last 4 rounds on saturday night before the AA fight and kes probably won the 12th and thats it

and yep he was losing to Taylor by quite a margin