Should Maidana have been deducted the point for the transaparent elbow?

[Memphis]

Nice to see the first two replies are sensible Saddo posters doing the site proud (stop arguing now guys. Julius you're going a bit OTT with the punishment ().

Don't worry miles, you and your gang of mug Khan haters will "win" this poll. Fact.

So, I don't do the site proud because I say things that don't fit with the mainstream? I am not so cool in the opinion of the MODS because I actually disagree with the Brit consensus that Khan is to be worshipped and that the point deduction was bogus?

What the fuck is it with people and just plaining making shit up? As always with these 'you all think the same' rants your way off the mark.

[Memphis]

Miles please show me one person Brit/MOD or otherwise who thinks Khans the second coming and I'll show you five who think otherwise.

[Gandalf]

Miles please show me one person Brit/MOD or otherwise who thinks Khans the second coming and I'll show you five who think otherwise.

No, I think I was off in that comment and I apologise to all the MODS. I have had a tough evening and have fallen apart somewhat.

I think I am right about the elbow, but I have no good reason to be rude to anybody.

[Memphis]

Miles please show me one person Brit/MOD or otherwise who thinks Khans the second coming and I'll show you five who think otherwise.

No, I think I was off in that comment and I apologise to all the MODS. I have had a tough evening and have fallen apart somewhat.

I think I am right about the elbow, but I have no good reason to be rude to anybody.

Miles you are forgiven

[Gandalf]

Miles please show me one person Brit/MOD or otherwise who thinks Khans the second coming and I'll show you five who think otherwise.

No, I think I was off in that comment and I apologise to all the MODS. I have had a tough evening and have fallen apart somewhat.

I think I am right about the elbow, but I have no good reason to be rude to anybody.

Miles you are forgiven

Thank you.

Just read the other board. I am not quite myself.

[fan johnny]

Maidana was hitting on the break often before the point deduction. The elbow was rather blantent so no prior warrning for the elbow was necessary, not only because of the deliberate foul, but in response to his previous warnings and unsportman like attitude from the onset of the fight. So I believe the deduction was completely justified.

[Kev]

What's funny is that as soon as it happened I said to Miles in the live rbr board that he should be happy as that will give him a bone of contention that he can insist was both wrong and cost Maidana the fight.............

[CFH]

Maidana was hitting on the break often before the point deduction. The elbow was rather blantent so no prior warrning for the elbow was necessary, not only because of the deliberate foul, but in response to his previous warnings and unsportman like attitude from the onset of the fight. So I believe the deduction was completely justified.

I think that's a fair perspective.

[Gandalf]

Nice to see the first two replies are sensible Saddo posters doing the site proud (stop arguing now guys. Julius you're going a bit OTT with the punishment ().

Don't worry miles, you and your gang of mug Khan haters will "win" this poll. Fact.

So, I don't do the site proud because I say things that don't fit with the mainstream? I am not so cool in the opinion of the MODS because I actually disagree with the Brit consensus that Khan is to be worshipped and that the point deduction was bogus?

What the fuck is it with people and just plaining making shit up? As always with these 'you all think the same' rants your way off the mark.

My main point was actually the former sentence, but regardless that highlighted sentence was me venting somewhat.

[bcollins]

I think the point deduction is well deserved. He deserved to lose a point for not connecting with Cortez' chin in a solid manner.

[CFH]

For the record, I think that Cortez did a pretty bad job, I just think there is some justification for the point deduction.

[Hulk]

The point deduction was bullshit.

Maidana was clearly just trying to touch gloves with Amir Khan.

[Kev]

The point deduction was bullshit.

Maidana was clearly just trying to touch gloves with Amir Khan.

haha and couldn't tell his fist from his elbow, or for that matter Amir's face from Cortez's chest.

[ono]

Lol yes. He elbowed the ref.

[:::PSL:::]

What if that elbow hit Khan or Cortez in the eyebrow or forehead. A single elbow strike is not that fataly dangerous but it can cause severe laceration. That could have ended the fight early.