Who will be remembered more fondly...

[bradlee180]

Too early to say, son. Have to reserve making a call until we see how Haye's career plays out. You ought to add kentucky floid chicken to the poll though because for 9 years fraud mayweather has ducked virtually ALL the best while somehow convincing many gullible sheep that he was a great fighter.

Hell, a good 5 years ago in 2006, floid already was being called out for cherry-picking and ducking the best guys while Pacquiao was busy fighting the 3 greatest Mexican fighters of the era...and multiple fights with each at that!

It's nice to see that fraud maywetaher is done with Boxing now; it's happened sooner rather than later, he will be going to jail where the dregs of society belong.



maywetaher is both the greatest DUCKER in the history of the sport and also the most over-rated in the history of the sport. He's a good skillful defensive boxer, but he ain't great by any stretch of the imagination. You gotta fight the best to earn that distinction...as Pacquiao has done.

[Saddo]

at the minute its Calzaghe all the way...

Haye has along way to go to match what Joe achived.

[MMASUX]

Calzaghe without a question.

[iamasadlittleboy]

Too early to say, son. Have to reserve making a call until we see how Haye's career plays out. You ought to add kentucky floid chicken to the poll though because for 9 years fraud mayweather has ducked virtually ALL the best while somehow convincing many gullible sheep that he was a great fighter.

Hell, a good 5 years ago in 2006, floid already was being called out for cherry-picking and ducking the best guys while Pacquiao was busy fighting the 3 greatest Mexican fighters of the era...and multiple fights with each at that!

It's nice to see that fraud maywetaher is done with Boxing now; it's happened sooner rather than later, he will be going to jail where the dregs of society belong.



maywetaher is both the greatest DUCKER in the history of the sport and also the most over-rated in the history of the sport. He's a good skillful defensive boxer, but he ain't great by any stretch of the imagination. You gotta fight the best to earn that distinction...as Pacquiao has done.

Was keeping it to two well known Brits.

[No Contest]

Sven Ottke.

[Gandalf]

Joe Calzaghe by a hundred billion miles. Calzaghe is one of my favourite fighters, Haye is most definitely not.

[skel1983]

Calzaghe quite easily.

[DaxxKahn]

Sven Ottke.

[Master]

Haye has not hit his peak yet. so Joe.

[TigerFan]

Definitely Joe...unless David beats Wladimir & Vitali. And I don't see that happening.

[Howlin Mad Missy]

both unlikeable arseholes

[JazMerkin]

Too early to say, son. Have to reserve making a call until we see how Haye's career plays out. You ought to add kentucky floid chicken to the poll though because for 9 years fraud mayweather has ducked virtually ALL the best while somehow convincing many gullible sheep that he was a great fighter.

Hell, a good 5 years ago in 2006, floid already was being called out for cherry-picking and ducking the best guys while Pacquiao was busy fighting the 3 greatest Mexican fighters of the era...and multiple fights with each at that!

It's nice to see that fraud maywetaher is done with Boxing now; it's happened sooner rather than later, he will be going to jail where the dregs of society belong.



maywetaher is both the greatest DUCKER in the history of the sport and also the most over-rated in the history of the sport. He's a good skillful defensive boxer, but he ain't great by any stretch of the imagination. You gotta fight the best to earn that distinction...as Pacquiao has done.

Jesus Christ man, you are obsessed, I don't remember seeing you post about anything else!

What DID he do to you? Not sign an autograph?? Sleep with your wife/girlfriend/mother/sister/all of the above?? Poke you & break into your security guard station??

You're insane.

Anyway moving on from this raving loon & back to the topic, I can't believe this is even a question. Calzaghe is a legitimate hall of famer, possibly the best 168lber there's been & arguably a 2 weight lineal champion. Not to mention he's fought at least 2 future hall of famers. Haye, hasn't fought any future hall of famers, is admittedly a lineal CW champ, & is a way off JC's achievements. He'll only be remembered more fondly if he fights & beats the Klitschkos.