Arturo Gatti vs Jose Luis Castillo @ 140

[JazMerkin]

Yeah just to be clear, I was refering to the specific period of about 2000-2004 when Gatti was fairly comfortable at 140 and (IMO) Castillo could of probably fought at 140, no problem.

In that timeframe it would have been Castillo all day for me. Loved Gatti, but Castillo was just on another level & while I don't think Gatti would have been embarassed, I think Castillo takes the win 75% of the time.

[The Fightfan]

I will disagree with most on the boards. I went with Gatti. I think at that time period Gatti was the better fighter.

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

Guys, don't forget to vote! (That means you Teath!)

And if you have voted without giving a reason why, well that's just crass.

[Nameless]

Yeah just to be clear, I was refering to the specific period of about 2000-2004 when Gatti was fairly comfortable at 140 and (IMO) Castillo could of probably fought at 140, no problem.

In that timeframe it would have been Castillo all day for me. Loved Gatti, but Castillo was just on another level & while I don't think Gatti would have been embarassed, I think Castillo takes the win 75% of the time.

I agree. No matter how much I loved Gatti and his tremendous power, I think that Castillo is too technical for Thunder and would be way too elusive.