Quote Originally Posted by :::PSL::: View Post
Quote Originally Posted by generalbulldog View Post
Quote Originally Posted by :::PSL::: View Post
Quote Originally Posted by generalbulldog View Post
Floyd as a welterweight has never been over 149. Pics really don't tell anything btw. De La Hoya looked bigger than Pac but was actually 1 or 2 pounds less than Pac on fightnight.

If we're talking about weight here, Floyd never had to weight drain his toughest foes to "even" the playing field. Since Pac is being called best p4p I just found it funny that he can't be like the former p4p like Floyd and fight them at their best weight.
Floyd did not fight Judah, Hatton, and JMM at their best weight. FACT
Manny didn't fight Barrera, Morales, Cotto, De La Hoya at their best weight. Fact.
I agree with you on Morales. I think his best weight class was 122.

Barrera was one of ring mag top 10 p4p fighter, reigning WBC title holder (eventhough he refused to accept the belt) and a lineal champ when Pac fought him the first time. So how can you say that's not his best weight class?

Cotto weighed in at 146 when he fought Clottey. So what's the big deal there? Pac started fighting 106.

About De La Hoya at 147. That was DHL's idea.
Barrera's best weight was 122 just like Morales. And if 1 or 2 pounds was no big deal as you are suggesting then why the catchweight fight? Easy to make Cotto weak that's why. So in reality Manny never fought MAB, EM, DLH, Cotto at their best. Only when they were long in the tooth and way past it did the fight was set up.

Just like this upcoming fight with Mosley. Mosley is shot, but Manny lovers like you will say he's "prime" and at his best right now.