What you have to understand is that most fighters have a peak period when they are good, which lasts only a few months. Before that time they were not ready, after, they are clearly shot. If it cannot be argued a fighter is either too green, or ready to be put to pasture, then clearly he must have been overated.

The fact is that by the above criteria Manny has not fought a single, prime athlete who was capable of testing him. His record is actually very mediocre when you examine it with the facts.