Was Zab Judah ever in your top 10 P4P?

[Dizaster]

I was just wondering this based on an old thread I came across about Zab and never fully meeting his potential..

I've never really taken to thinking about and creating my own P4P list.. I read others and agree with certain things and disagree with others, and obviously can pick the few boxers i'd have at the top... But as i've never made a P4P list in the past, i've never considered where Zab would have fitten in P4P at different stages of his career, vs other fighters at the time...

What is the highest you would have had him, especially if he was ever in your top 10, and when/what was it for. i.e. what performance or opponent did he beat to get in there?

[rjj tszyu]

Going into the Tszyu fight yes without doubt.

[Kev]

Yeah for sure. He was p4p after the Spinks win going into the Baldomir fight too.

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

Yeah back when Majesty was Purist.

[Ant Live]

After Zab beat JMM he will be!

[BIG H]

Yeah back when Majesty was Purist.

[THE THIRD MAN]

In 2001 he was for sure, remember that many had him as a favourite to beat Tszyu, too fast and too slick they all said.

[the wiz]

After the Spinks win for sure. He was the undisputed welterweight champion. To me Judah is one of the biggest "what could of beens" Even though he's had a very good career it could of been so much better. I would of had the Mayweather fight scored a draw for Zab if the knockdown of Floyd would of correctly been determined it was a knockdown.

[DaxxKahn]

Like most I had him in before the loss to Kostya then he was out but back in after he beats Spinks....After that it was all just downhill and disappointment as a fan perspective...Fucking guy has the good to be an ATG but mental makeup of shit!!

[CutMeMick]

Dont think I had him in the top 10 in 2001 like some people... Pre-Kostya.
Just looking briefly at some footnotes in my book looks like late 2001.
I had something like SSM, RJJ, B-Hop, PBF, MAB, Trinidad, Lopez, ODLH, Kostya and Morales.


I think early 2005 after the Spinks win he hit the 9 or 10 spot briefly.

Yeah back when Majesty was Purist.

Great reference...