I guess ODLH rep hinges on how seriously one takes the official record. There's an argument to be made that Boxing is different. Because of its inherent subjectivity (along with corruption) offical scores mean less that they do in other sports. And close wins are not the same as decisive ones, since things could easily go the other way.
This analysis also excludes Sweat Pea and Chavez, presumably becase they were not in their prime, but then simultaneously includes PBF and PacMan, even though ODLH was not prime by then. Not to mention Hopkins size.
One thing I like about boxing is, more than any other sport, its not whether you win or lose but how you played the game.
Bookmarks