Prime ODLH beats Manny and floyd

[0james0]

I don't think he would have ever beat them prime for prime.

He was great, those two are something else. Oscar did well because he looked good and was a nice guy.

[ICB]

I don't think he would have ever beat them prime for prime.

He was great, those two are something else. Oscar did well because he looked good and was a nice guy.

Put it this way though would a prime ODLH, have lost to anyone on there resumes P4P ? i see ODLH having no problem beating anyone on Mayweather's or Pacquiao's resume.

[0james0]

I don't think he would have ever beat them prime for prime.

He was great, those two are something else. Oscar did well because he looked good and was a nice guy.

Put it this way though would a prime ODLH, have lost to anyone on there resumes P4P ? i see ODLH having no problem beating anyone on Mayweather's or Pacquiao's resume.

Can't really argue that, would have loved to have seen him vs Hatton though!

But I still think that they are both too good for him, their opponents maybe not, but I'd still pick those two everytime.

Not that Oscar isn't brilliant, just Manny and Floyd are a different class.

So subjective though, leads on nicely to Mosley vs in his prime. Many would pick Floyd and Manny, which surely would mean by rights they should beat Oscar?

[ICB]

I don't think he would have ever beat them prime for prime.

He was great, those two are something else. Oscar did well because he looked good and was a nice guy.

Put it this way though would a prime ODLH, have lost to anyone on there resumes P4P ? i see ODLH having no problem beating anyone on Mayweather's or Pacquiao's resume.

Can't really argue that, would have loved to have seen him vs Hatton though!

But I still think that they are both too good for him, their opponents maybe not, but I'd still pick those two everytime.

Not that Oscar isn't brilliant, just Manny and Floyd are a different class.

So subjective though, leads on nicely to Mosley vs in his prime. Many would pick Floyd and Manny, which surely would mean by rights they should beat Oscar?

Im not so sure Manny Pacquiao would beat a prime Shane Mosley, i think people forget how good Shane Mosley was until he was ruined. And ODLH only lost by 1 or 2 rounds vs Shane Mosley, and should of won the rematch.

And even Floyd Mayweather Jr at Welterweight, didn't have opposition like Trinidad, Quartey, ETC. Actually im not that impressed with Floyd Mayweather's resume above Lightweight.

[Kev]

What weight would these fights be taking place at?

Manny vs Oscar at lightweight would be interesting, Floyd vs Oscar at light welter too.

Id pick Manny and Floyd.

If you want to put Oscar in the welterweight or light middle divisions however I think he wouldnt be fighting the best Floyd or Manny either.

its impossible to put them both in the ring in their primes and prime weights as they are different sized fighters......

[0james0]

It's such an impossible result to really call. Let's not forget Oscar even shared a ring with our favourite grandad. The weights are too all over.